(NEW) ELAC 4" Passive Wired Bookshelf Speakers

Update 2/2: A note for those of you out there that, like most people, have limited options for speaker placement… Yes, it’s important to be aware of how close the speakers are to the wall (or all six surfaces for that matter), but don’t forget about the space between them. My system is in a shared space, so either side of a TV in surrounding bookshelves was what it was gonna be. This ended up being about 6’ apart, 1’ from the back wall, >6’ from the nearest sidewall, and about 13’ to the listening position (a couch on the opposite wall). I was aware of the “isosceles” guidelines for a listening position, and I realized they were probably too close together for 13’ but it really felt like the only option at the time (mainly for aesthetic reasons in a shared space). Long story short, one Saturday, I decided to try moving them laterally to the opposite edge of their respective shelves (extending the distance to ~8’). It was like a different system. Toeing is important, but even before tuning that, the less direct sound leaves much more canvas for your brain to paint on and for the first time in 2 years, the speakers disappeared✨ It probably also doesn’t hurt getting a bit further from the reflective TV. Thankfully, “shareholders” of the space found it visually acceptable and I haven’t looked back 😅 Honestly, it’s making me rethink my goal of a 5.1 system - not sure I need it! I wanted to share this to underscore if these are your first speakers, they will grow with your system. Will better speakers sound better with upgraded components? Most likely. Do the BS41’s have a ceiling? Absolutely, and proportionately lower. But they’ve responded to everything I’ve added, and that support pushes them past the price I paid (in my experience/opinion). ✌️ 5/1/25 Update1/2: So, I’ve had these for over a year now and I’m here to report life is good - particularly as I’ve learned to tune the system and make some technical upgrades, the value of these speakers (to my ear) has increased. I generally subscribed to the philosophy that one “works their way in” from the speakers when building a system and when cycling through upgrades… But my experience lead me to question that. My living situation did not make it practical to upgrade my speakers, but the enduring interest had me upgrading components “ahead of schedule,” including a notable leap from a Schiit Modi3+ to a Denafrips Ares 12th 😅. A more modest change has been getting in early on Fosi V3 Monos and dropping some Sparkos SS3602's in their buffer stage [all seen in second photo]. That, combined with being a bit smarter with the sub, these Elac’s continue to come to life! As I said, I started to wonder if working my way in was the wrong idea, but I realized the lesson was if the perceived value of the speakers went up, I’d be within the same cycle :) All that to say, if your room is in moderate shape, you do your homework with gear, and take electrical interference seriously, you should not feel bad about paying more than $150 for these. The question rather, is where’s your line to save up? 7/10/24 Original review: The pic is what’s currently feeding the BS41’s (out of frame is also an Airmotiv SE8 subwoofer), but I started with just the Elac’s, an Aiyima A08 Pro, and my Pro-Ject T1 Phono SB (and it steadily grew from there since March of this year). It’s my first system, and my first set of speakers, so I don’t have a lot to compare it to (to say nothing of the odd room size) but I think they sound great! In retrospect, I probably should have saved up a for one of the front-ported models (my only options in my current living space is to have them fewer than 12in from the wall), but I don’t regret owning these. That said, if they go over $150, I recommend saving for the step-up. The rumors are true, these put out a surprising amount of bass, and there’s no “glistening” top end, but they’re not muffled by any means. Their focus is punch for their size and price, and they nail it in my opinion. Not the common scenario, but I have the high-pass filter on the sub set at 60, which I think helped tighten the woofers, and the upper mids definitely enjoyed the extra juice. I also have the Schiit Lokius adding some support for the highs. All in all, I think these are a great entry level speaker for the 2.1 listener that likes it on the warm side (as I do). BUT, truly consider something front-ported if you know these are going to be against the wall.