(NEW) Echo Dot (3rd Gen, 2018) - Smart Speaker
$16.99
$49.99
66% off
Reference Price
Color: Charcoal
Condition: New
Top positive review
14 people found this helpful
Improved version of the already brilliant 2nd gen. Echo Dot, excluding the mic.
By OVR Guy on Reviewed in the United States on March 9, 2019
Summary: The third generation of the Amazon Echo Dot smart speaker is better in many aspects from the already brilliant Echo Dot 2nd generation. Only one thing really bothered me about it, which is the built-in microphone, which appears to be inferior to the previous model. Since I already own the Amazon Echo Dot 2nd generation and the Google Home Mini, these are the comparison benchmarks that I can relate to in my review. The sound that comes out from the Echo Dot 3rd generation is pleasant to the human ears. It isn't meant to replace a true speaker if you plan to listen to quality audio, but it is adequate for background music in a small space (such as a room). As for how it's like compared to my benchmark smart speakers - The 3rd gen's sound is better compared to the Amazon Echo 2nd generation, and in certain aspects, it is better than the Google Home Mini. In my opinion, the Google Home Mini offers a more balanced sound and better "mid" range, while the Echo Dot 3rd generation has better bass and more impactful "surround" sound. The 3rd generation Echo Dot is louder than the 2nd generation and the Google Home Mini. While testing the Echo Dot 3rd generation, I've placed the device in one specific room, and the maximum volume level sounded too much for this space (3x4 meters). So though the audio quality sounds great, and there's not that much of a distortion, I prefer not to set the device to its maximum volume level. What I did is to set the 3rd gen to volume level 7, and it is about as equal as the Google Home Min at 100% volume level. If the Echo Dot 2nd generation looks like a hockey puck, then the 3rd generation looks like a stylish & sophisticated donut. It's larger & heavier compared to the previous model, but it's hard to go wrong which one is the newer model. Since the Echo Dot is Amazon's most affordable smart home speaker, it's good that Amazon offers it for about the same price. I purchased it during Black Friday/Cyber Monday 2018 when it was relatively new, for $23 (as part of a deal that included 3 units for $69). It's not always offered for this price, and Amazon should have the interest to keep the price low, but I still appreciate the fact that Amazon didn't raise the price of the intelligent device compared to the 2nd generation's price. For some reason, I never used the Bluetooth capabilities of my 2nd generation Echo Dot and Google Home Mini. In fact, I totally forgot they exist... That's why I was glad to "re-discover" this so obvious feature is available on the Echo Dot 3rd generation - And it works well with my other devices! Right from the start, I suspected that the newer model is less responsive. At first, I thought that the increased volume level prevents what I say to be heard. Every time I talk to the device, I test if it can hear my voice – sometimes I whisper, other times I talk while there’s music playing in the background, and I’m quite sure the built-in mic isn’t improved compared to the previous model. I think the main reason why Alexa misses some of the things I'm saying stems from the fact that the 2nd generation Echo Dot had a 7-microphone array, while the newer model has 4 microphones. The 3rd generation Echo Dot is powered using a power adapter. I don't mind the power adapter takes more space compared to the USB cable that energized the previous model, but I guess that as a result of the improvements in the audio/volume/size of the newer model, it consumes more power (15W compared to 9W), than the Echo Dot 2nd generation Overall, it seems that Amazon understands its customer’s needs and managed to improve the new Echo Dot so it would offer more features & better quality for about the same price range. Please note I attached to this review screenshots + a video review I made about my experience with the Amazon Echo Dot 3rd generation. The pros: - Improved audio quality compared to the previous model. - Higher volume level compared to my benchmark device. - Stylish design. - Price remains attractive. - Bluetooth connection. The cons: - It is less responsive compared to the 2nd generation of the Amazon Echo Dot. - Bluetooth connection. - The device consumes more energy compared to the 2nd generation. **** FAQ : **** If you have any, please do ask and I will do my best to answer them.
Top critical review
133 people found this helpful
Not very intelligent and extremely frustrating.
By Deb on Reviewed in the United States on November 4, 2018
I like controlling my lights and setting timers and alarms with the Echo Dots, however I'm frustrated more often than not with them. And, frankly, before having the Echo Dots I controlled my lights with Siri on my iPhone and iPad, so it's not like I'm getting much more functionality out of them. I find the Dot is constantly making mistaking. Examples: - I was trying out the music and asked it to play 'old music'. It kept repeating back, "Great, I'll play Soul Music", then it would start to play soul music. 5-6 times this happened. And, no, it doesn't apparently understand a negative, such as, "Alexa, do not play Soul Music," because that statement immediately triggers it to say, "Great, I'll play Soul Music" and then it starts to play soul music again. (Nothing against Soul Music, it's just not what I wanted.) I never did get what I wanted. - I will tell it to play sleep sounds. It will tell me either that I have to download the app, which I have already done or that it can't find the sleep sound that I requested, even if it played the night before. Or worse, it will start to play music related to the sleep sound that I asked for. (I never knew there were so many songs related to rain or trains.) After a half dozen or more tries and screaming, "Alexa, STOP!" repeatedly, I am no longer able to even think about sleeping, even if it does finally get it right! -I will tell it to turn on the living room light and it will tell me I have to set it up in the app. It IS set up to turn the lights on and off and it has completed this command many times. Although, I am finding this command is gradually getting better, but it's not perfect, yet. -I will tell tell it to play an Audible book and it will tell me that I have to buy the book from Amazon, even though I already own the book through Audible.com (an Amazon company) and have played it several times before on that very Dot. What is most annoying is that often I just want to know something basic, like today I wanted to know what date was Thanksgiving Day. Instead of simply telling me the date, it gave me a long history of how the date came about and never did give me the date. Out of every 10 commands, it is a guarantee that 7-8 commands will have to be repeated, changed, broken down into simpler steps or started over multiple times. I find myself screaming "Alexa, stop!" in frustration constantly, as it rambles on incorrectly or plays something incorrectly. (And I am accent-free, with very clear speech.) Not to mention the apps, of which they tout are so many tens of thousands, are pretty useless. For instance, I had heard I could make a list on it, such as a grocery list or To-Do list. Yeah, I can, but the grocery list is in the Dot and not anyplace useful; it doesn't link to my Grocery app or Things 3 app on my computer or phone, for example. It is buried deep in the Alexa app, which is totally inconvenient. If I want it in my Grocery or Things 3 apps I have to play it back and manually transfer it line by line. Set-up, which I had read was a breeze, was anything but. I had to contact Amazon customer service, which itself is difficult to find, then it took them a good 40 minutes to help me get the Dot to work. I am very disappointed in the sound quality, too. It is not good enough to make me want to listen to music through it, at all. I will listen to books, but frankly ear buds have much better sound quality and make the listening a richer experience. When Alexa is playing something, like answering a question or giving a daily brief, the volume goes up and down ridiculously. One statement will blow you off the bed, while the other will be very quiet. Regarding listening to Audible books, now that is extremely frustrating! I bought 2 Echo Dots, one for the bedroom and one for the living room, specifically so I could listen to Audible books while moving around my apartment. Audible.com is an Amazon company, so you would think that they would integrate the linking of the Dots together for playback. Nope! After talking to Customer Service, I found out that only music can be linked to play back on both Dots simultaneously. Audible.com books can only play back on one Dot or the other at one time. How stupid is that? I find being more than 5-7 feet away from the Dot makes it very iffy on whether it will correctly hear what I say. How is it helpful if I have to walk to within a few feet of the Dot to ask it turn off the lights, when walking 3 more feet I could turn off the lights by hand? I've put the Dots so many places trying to find the best places for them and decided that I wish it had batteries so I could just carry it around. I guess this is how they get you to buy 20 of them for your apartment. I thought I would love these, but it's like thinking you are buying powerful motorcycles and getting a couple of tricycles instead. Maybe if I were into trivia and games I would like them more, but I want them to accomplish more important things, not just be toys.
Sort by:
Filter by:
Sorry, no reviews match your current selections.
Try clearing or changing some filters.Show all reviews
Show more reviews